JavaScript is disabled for your browser. Some features of this site may not work without it.
  • About K
  • Academics
  • Admission
  • Alumni Relations
  • Giving to K
  • News & Events
  • Student Life
  • HORNET HIVE
  • ATHLETICS
  • SITEMAP
  • WEBMAIL
    • Login
    View Item 
    •   CACHE Homepage
    • Academic Departments, Programs, and SIPs
    • History
    • History Senior Integrated Projects
    • View Item
    •   CACHE Homepage
    • Academic Departments, Programs, and SIPs
    • History
    • History Senior Integrated Projects
    • View Item

    French Universalism and Jewish Particularity : French Jewish Identity from Emancipation to WWI

    Thumbnail
    View/Open
    Searchable PDF/Kalamazoo College Only (147.8Kb)
    Date
    2022-03-01
    Author
    Lulkin, Emily
    Metadata
    Show full item record
    Abstract
    French Jews saw unprecedented prosperity in 19th century France due to the universalist ideas that led to their emancipation. At the time, they were the only Jews in Europe who could actively participate in the educational, political, and economic institutions of their country. However, the Dreyfus Affair exposed the disadvantages of the rigid French universalist ideals that didn’t align with the Jews’ distinct sense of community and culture. These differing identities among French Jews do not necessarily align with the assimilationist version of universalism that had been subscribed to pre- Dreyfus Affair. Maurice Samuels suggests a spectrum to describe different versions of universalism; on one side of the spectrum would be assimilation and the other side of the spectrum would be pluralism. The far side of the assimilation pole represents the traditional French universalism which would expect Jews to shed any distinction from the majority culture in the political, cultural, economic or religious sense. The pluralist side of the spectrum would be represented by an embracement and acceptance of different minority groups’ distinctions by society and the state, with the acknowledgment that there are still certain universal rights and values among our differences.45 Judaism is deeply rooted in community (e.g. needing ten people to form a minion for certain prayers, the formation of social societies, the celebration of holidays, etc.), but it is not a monolith and each individual must decide for themselves what it means to be Jewish. The endless interpretations of what it means to be Jewish results in many particular Jewish communities, linked together by a common identity; universalism with the acceptance of pluralism. The same holds true for French identity; each Frenchman has their own idea on what it means to be French. Their ideas on what French identity is may differ- as I discussed before, French citizenship and French nationality are not always equated to each other- but they still share a universal identity, whether it be through cultural similarities or just by living in the same country. This pluralistic universalism does not align with the version of assimilationist universalism that the writers of The Declaration of the Rights of Man and the Citizen intended. The “French universalism” that Samuels defined is more of a prescriptive idea than a description of how universalism has actually worked in France. No group is a monolith; difference and diversity are inevitable wherever freedom reigns, so France has mostly functioned as a pluralistic universalist society. While each French Jew may articulate their identities differently, they still define themselves the same way: as French Jews. I’ve been using the writing of Maurice Samuels as a base for the definitions of universalism and pluralism, and I think the title of his book perfectly encapsulates what French Jewish identity is all about: The Right to Difference. No matter how differently two French Jews express or relate to their identities, the universal right to difference means that neither is more or less French or Jewish than the other. The ambiguity of these identities can lead to gate keeping and exclusion, as I’ve written about, but it also means that each individual can pick and choose which aspects of these identities that are meaningful to them while still being a part of a shared community; universalism with the acceptance of pluralism.
    URI
    https://cache.kzoo.edu/handle/10920/43693
    Collections
    • History Senior Integrated Projects [664]

    Related items

    Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.

    • Thumbnail

      A Study of Kibbutz Living: Experiencing Jewish Community and Analyzing Jewish Identity 

      Stevens, Catherine L. (Kalamazoo, Mich. : Kalamazoo College, 1979)
      This study examines the modern striving of the Jewish people in the new State of Israel. It was my privilege to be accepted for a work-study program (Ulpan) at Kibbutz Merchavia for the time period between July 1978-November ...
    • Thumbnail

      The Christian-Jewish Tragedy 

      Start, Lester J., 1919-2001
      Sermon given by Dr. Lester Start. Undated.
    • Thumbnail

      HIST 252: Emancipation, Assimilation and Anti-Semitism: European Jewish History, 1789-1945 

      Hoolihan, Mark (2005)
      This course examines the turbulent history of European Jews from the French Revolution to the Holocaust. This time period witnessed opportunities for emancipation and even assimilation into European culture which Jews had ...

    Browse

    All of DSpaceCommunities & CollectionsBy Issue DateAuthorsTitlesSubjectsThis CollectionBy Issue DateAuthorsTitlesSubjects

    My Account

    Login

    DSpace software copyright © 2002-2022  DuraSpace
    DSpace Express is a service operated by 
    Atmire NV
    Logo

    Kalamazoo College
    1200 Academy Street
    Kalamazoo Michigan 49006-3295
    USA
    Info 269-337-7000
    Admission 1-800-253-3602

    About K
    Academics
    Admission
    Alumni Relations
    Giving to K
    News & Events
    Student Life
    Sitemap
    Map & Directions
    Contacts
    Directories
    Nondiscrimination Policy
    Consumer Information
    Official disclaimer
    Search this site


    Academic Calendars
    Apply
    Bookstore
    Crisis Response
    Employment
    Library
    Registrar
    DSpace Express is a service operated by 
    Atmire NV